When a royalty check looks lower than the production volumes would suggest, the difference is often in the deductions. Some of those deductions are taxes. Others are post-production charges. Understanding the difference, and how they show up on a statement, makes a monthly review much easier.

Production costs and post-production costs are not the same thing

In broad terms, production costs are the costs of getting oil or gas out of the ground: drilling, completing, operating, and maintaining the well. Royalty owners typically do not share those operating costs, which is one reason a royalty interest is different from a working interest.

Post-production costs are the costs incurred after the hydrocarbons have been produced, to put them in a condition and location for sale. Common examples include gathering, transportation, compression, dehydration, treating, processing, fractionation, and marketing. On a gas well, those charges can be a meaningful part of the value shown on the statement.

How these charges appear on a statement

Some payers list post-production items as separate lines, with a volume, a rate, and an amount. Others net the charges into a realized price, so you see a lower unit price and little or no detail about what was taken out. A statement can also use abbreviations or codes that are not obvious if you do not have the payer’s legend.

If you only see a net price, it is reasonable to ask the payer for a breakdown of the deductions behind that price. You cannot compare a charge with your lease if you cannot see the charge. Month-to-month consistency matters too. A new code, a new vendor, or a sudden increase in a familiar deduction is a signal to look closer.

The lease usually matters more than a rule of thumb

There is no single nationwide rule that every post-production deduction is allowed, or that none of them are. Many leases speak to the point, sometimes clearly and sometimes in older language that takes careful reading. Some leases provide for payment on gross proceeds. Others allow certain costs to be deducted, or calculate royalty on proceeds at a particular point of sale. Marketing, transportation, and processing may be treated differently from one lease to the next.

Division orders and purchaser contracts can also affect how a payment is calculated, but they generally should not take away rights the lease already grants. If the statement and the lease seem to say different things, that gap is worth reviewing before you assume either one is simply a paperwork issue.

State law can matter as well. Oklahoma and Texas, for example, do not always treat these questions the same way, and the result in any given case still turns on the facts and the documents. This is general information, not a conclusion about your lease.

What royalty owners should check

When you review post-production deductions, keep the statement, the lease, and a few prior months together:

  • List every deduction or netted adjustment and the amount taken.
  • Ask for a breakdown when the statement shows only a net price or an unexplained code.
  • Compare the charges with the lease language on royalty, proceeds, and costs.
  • Watch for new deductions, rate changes, or charges that appear on one well but not on a similar well under the same lease.
  • Separate taxes from post-production items, and confirm that tax rates look consistent with prior months.

Working-interest owners may also see midstream and marketing costs, but they will often appear in a different place, including on a joint interest billing. Royalty and overriding royalty interest owners should focus first on the revenue statement, because that is where a post-production deduct usually affects the check.

When a deduction deserves a closer review

A deduction is not automatically improper because it reduced your check. It is also not automatically proper because it appeared on an official-looking statement. The questions are more practical: Is the charge described clearly? Does it match the lease? Is the volume or rate consistent with other months? If the hydrocarbons were sold at the well, is a downstream charge still being taken? If several affiliates are in the chain between the well and the sale, is the deduction supported?

Those are the same points we look for in a revenue statement review. If you want a structured way to go through them, use our free audit checklist. It includes a section on revenue-statement deductions, along with the interest and decimal checks that should come first. You can also book a call and we can look at a statement with you.